Obligations vs. duties

Reader comment on: Budgets and Brothers

Submitted by Don Watkins (United States), Jul 19, 2011 23:58

Thanks for taking note of our column, Ira, and for your thoughtful comments. I think, however, that framing the issue in terms of "circles of obligation" clouds the issue because it blurs a crucial distinction: obligations an individual voluntarily accepts in pursuit of his own interests, and unchosen obligations an individual supposedly has that demand him to sacrifice his interests.

I would argue that a person pursuing his self-interest has all sorts of voluntarily-accepted obligations. For instance, I have obligations to treat my wife a certain way, not as some painful duty, but in order to foster a relationship that means a tremendous amount to me. Similarly, I'm contractually obligated to write the best columns I can for my employer.

That is radically different from the idea that there are people I have a self-sacrificial duty to help regardless of their value to me. Once you accept that idea, it doesn't matter whether you happen to think it applies only to certain others. You've conceded the essential issue: the individual is not sovereign, and the needs of his neighbor trump his pursuit of happiness. It's hard to see how you can then defend against the person who says that your "neighbor" ought to include your entire town, or city, or county, or planet. Indeed, isn't that what moralists like Peter Singer (to say nothing of Christian theorists) have argued?

In my view, you can't fight the welfare state by defending the welfare town. You have to fight for the individual's moral and political right to pursue his own self-interest.

Ayn Rand addresses some of these issues at http://aynrandlexicon.com/lexicon/charity.html and http://aynrandlexicon.com/lexicon/sacrifice.html. I encourage anyone interested to take a look.

Note: Comments are moderated by the editor and are subject to editing.

Other reader comments on this item

Title By Date
⇒ Obligations vs. duties [278 words]Don WatkinsJul 19, 2011 23:58
Let help be optional, based on values, rather than duty oriented [156 words]Gideon ReichJul 19, 2011 16:50
Which is it?
[w/response] [183 words]
John GillisJul 18, 2011 17:55
Being one's actual brother's keeper [283 words]John GillisJul 18, 2011 18:36

Comment on this item

Mark my comment as a response to Obligations vs. duties by Don Watkins

Email me if someone replies to my comment

Note: Comments are moderated by the editor and are subject to editing.