Reader comment on: The War on For-Profit Education
Submitted by John Beck (United States), Nov 14, 2010 23:27
There are no comparison figures given for percentages of revenue from government sources for other universities. Right under the Times's nose in New York City, for example, there exists something called the City University of New York, which gets 50% of its funding from taxpayers of the state of New York, and 11% from taxpayers of the City of New York. Of the remaining 39% that comes from tuition payments, $329 million of it came from federal Pell Grants.
Is uninstructive. You use percentages up until the end, but by not telling us what that $329 million is a percentage of, we cannot make a comparison. If it's $329 million out of $1 billion, then it's scandalous that for-profit schools take a larger percentage of funding from the federal government than not-for-profit. if it's $329 million out of $330 million, then it's incredibly scandalous how little comes from non-governmental sources. Why do you switch gears like that? Why do you deliberately obstruct the ability for the reader to make informed comparisons by changing the measurement metric in mid 'graph?
While I want to agree with your article, you're engaging in tactics quite similar to those at the NYT which you decry: using a big scary number in place of a number with which the reader can make meaningful comparison.
Note: Comments are moderated by the editor and are subject to editing.
Submit a comment on this article
Other reader comments on this item
|You're on to Something [102 words]||ross crawford||Nov 15, 2010 21:06|
|Federal Funding for Private Companies [38 words]||Bob||Nov 15, 2010 14:01|
|They actually pay taxes [60 words]||BTN||Nov 15, 2010 11:27|
|Conflict of Interest? [357 words]||J.Johnson||Nov 15, 2010 11:12|
|⇒ Unnecessary Obfuscation [221 words]||John Beck||Nov 14, 2010 23:27|
|For profit article based on ideology, not reality [138 words]||D. Melvil Dewey||Nov 14, 2010 06:42|
|Really off base here [68 words]||Penn6020||Nov 12, 2010 23:41|
|Thank you.... [269 words]||Marlon R. Graves||Nov 12, 2010 19:26|
|Earned??? HAH! [22 words]||WhoProfits||Nov 12, 2010 16:51|
Comment on this item