Amendments are as American as apple pie

Reader comment on: Schumer Versus The First Amendment

Submitted by ben (United States), Nov 23, 2011 20:08

The argument that we should not tinker with the constitution is nonsense. If we didn't, African-Americans would still be 3/5ths of a person and women would not be voting. The founders knew that they could not anticipate every eventuality, so they built a mechanism into the constitution that allowed it to change. Amending the constitution is a very difficult thing to do, requiring the overwhelming support of the people. Of course, the people won't need 99% to get this amendment passed, but this is clearly in response to the growing feeling that the government is rigged. The campaign finance system is broken. Politicians are at the mercy of their donors and do what will bring in the fundraising, not necessarily what is right for the country. I would be more in favor of a system like Bruce Ackerman has outlined in which everyone would get a certain amount of money to give to whichever candidate he/she would like. Relative to the size and importance of our political campaigns, I don't think there is too much money involved, but rather that the money is coming from too few contributors who then expect payback. Amend away.

As for campaign commercials, I am not sure your proposal will be any more effective than a simple graphic showing where a particular candidate gets his/her money from. The 1% really do control the political process to a frightening extent.

Note: Comments are moderated by the editor and are subject to editing.

The Future of Capitalism replies:

I'm not saying we shouldn't tinker with the Constitution. The First Amendment was a tinkering with the Constitution. But it's such a fine amendment that I don't think it needs fixing.

Submit a comment on this article

Other reader comments on this item

Title By Date
Tweaking of First Amendment [117 words]Gina PryorNov 26, 2011 22:17
⇒ Amendments are as American as apple pie
[w/response] [234 words]
benNov 23, 2011 20:08
Elections have changed a bit
[w/response] [51 words]
benNov 23, 2011 22:59
FOC I agree with you here [73 words]Orange thunderNov 24, 2011 20:05
Congress doesn't really declare war anymore anyway [146 words]benNov 24, 2011 21:26
What's the point? [123 words]MattNov 28, 2011 06:30

Comment on this item

Mark my comment as a response to Amendments are as American as apple pie by ben

Email me if someone replies to my comment

Note: Comments are moderated by the editor and are subject to editing.